Penfield Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining The Peppered Pig $$ 127 reviews New American, French (585) 347-6479 1759 Empire BlvdWebster, NY 14580 Signatures At The Humphrey House $$ 117 reviews New American, Bars (585) 267-7415 1783 Penfield RdPenfield, NY 14526 Michael's Valley Grill $$ 109 reviews Steakhouses, American (585) 383-8260 1694 Penfield RdRochester, NY 14526 The Five Mile Cafe $ 141 reviews Cafes, Breakfast & Brunch (585) 586-2232 2084 Five Mile Line RdPenfield, NY 14526 Guacamole Tacos & Margaritas $$ 215 reviews Tacos, Cocktail Bars (585) 662-5744 1778 Penfield RdPenfield, NY 14526 Rustic Taco $ 54 reviews Tacos (585) 364-0703 50 S Main StSte 30 Cobblestone On Main $$ 74 reviews New American, Burgers, Soup (585) 626-4450 109 W Main StWebster, NY 14580 Great American Diner $ 105 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Diners, Waffles (585) 364-0255 650 Whitney RdFairport, NY 14450 Wildflour $ 22 reviews Pasta Shops, Grocery, Pizza 620 N Winton RdRochester, NY 14609 The Magnet Fried Chicken $$ 158 reviews Chicken Shop (585) 348-9729 1794 Penfield RdPenfield, NY 14526 Joegatt’s Food & Cocktails $$ 88 reviews Burgers, Tapas/Small Plates, Cocktail Bars (585) 485-0631 2126 5 Mile Line RdPenfield, NY 14526 The Penfield Pour House $$ 111 reviews American, Sports Bars (585) 264-1665 1665 Penfield RdRochester, NY 14625 Fattoush Restaurant $ 76 reviews Mediterranean (585) 267-7876 5 S Main StPittsford, NY 14534 The Original Steve's Diner $ 444 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Mediterranean, Greek (585) 248-9996 1694 Penfield RdRochester, NY 14526 Lemoncello Italian Restaurant & Bar $$ 317 reviews Italian, Music Venues, Wine Bars (585) 385-8565 137 W Commercial StEast Rochester, NY 14445 Charley Brown's Restaurant $$ 85 reviews New American (585) 385-9202 1675 Penfield RdRochester, NY 14625 Donnelly's Public House $$ 149 reviews American, Pubs (585) 377-5450 1 Water StFairport, NY 14450 Brimont Bistro $$ 59 reviews Caterers, French (585) 872-3170 24 W Main StWebster, NY 14580 Steven James Coffee $ 3 reviews Coffee & Tea, Breakfast & Brunch, Juice Bars & Smoothies (585) 203-1174 349 West Commercial StEast Rochester, NY 14445 Yanhuang Gourmet $ 42 reviews Chinese (585) 598-3114 4400 Fairport Nine Mile Point RdFairport, NY 14450 Rosey's Italian Cafe $$ 91 reviews Italian (585) 385-5600 2133 Five Mile Line RdPenfield, NY 14526 Hollycake House $$ 24 reviews Vegan, Bakeries, Cafes (585) 310-7728 300 Main StSte 25 Jack's Extra Fancy $ 11 reviews Dive Bars, New American, Cocktail Bars 825 Atlantic AveRochester, NY 14609 Capone’s Italian Eatery $ 16 reviews Pizza, Sandwiches, Italian (585) 267-7588 1811 Penfield RdPenfield, NY 14526